I tried appealing a perms ban on my main account (banned for gather buddy) and it got denied.. I'm going to send another appeal though.. Should I claim I got hacked or what's the best way to appeal a permanent ban? This is an old account (~6 years) and has been in good standing.
If you didn't juggle IP's and MACs they have no reason to believe you had your account hijacked. But as I see it you've nothing to lose
Whatever story you spun in the first ticket I would continue with in the second. They will look as past tickets so they stay up to date on what they say and if you go from I didn't do anything wrong to I was hacked they know you are just trying to trick them into giving you your account back.